The now Rising Stars Challenge has become one of the most exciting events in NBA All-Star Weekend, with its format having recently been changed to eliminate the class distinction. Still, one of the cool things about the NBA Draft process is that players getting drafted together and coming into the league together often become friends, and are connected to some extent throughout their careers. The Rookie-Sophomore/ Rising Stars Challenge has been part of that.
So, I decided to be a nerd and sort of expand the Rookie/Sophomore Challenge to include every draft class in a sort of “mega” All-Star Weekend–an idea which might not make a whole lot of sense for the players, but I think would be really cool to see as a fan. Here’s how it works:
Of the 24 All-Stars this year, 12 draft classes are represented: 2018, 2017, ‘16, ‘14, ‘13, ‘12, ‘11, ‘09, ‘08, ‘06, ‘05, and ‘03. Each class fills out its roster (somehow) with whichever non-All Stars would help most in a 12-team single elimination tournament. The teams are then seeded by the following criteria: (1) number of All-Stars, (2) number of All-Star starters, (3) All-Stars who happened to be hurt and missed the cut (in this hypothetical world where everyone is healthy and the tournament has no physical effect or risk), (4) seniority. What follows is a more balanced All-Star tournament that gives more guys a chance to have the ball and show out and also might be a cool way to recognize older players who have been in the league for a long time.
So, hypothetically speaking, it’s February 16 and time to see which draft class can field the best team.
ROUND 1
MATCHUP 1
(8) Class of 2009 vs
(9) Class of 2003
The class of 2009 are halfway through their eleventh seasons in the NBA. In a draft class originally known for its plethora of quality starting point guards (Steph Curry, Jrue Holiday, Brandon Jennings, Ty Lawson, Jeff Teague, Ricky Rubio, Darren Collison), the only ones left starting are Curry, Holiday, Rubio, and the late bloomer Pat Beverley.
LeBron James, Carmelo Anthony and Kyle Korver would actually be a pretty deadly 3-on-3 team. But in this 3-on-5 matchup, Kyle Korver is left guarding two players while Melo half-guards Taj Gibson and LeBron plays quarterback. Offensively, Kyle Korver finds a way to get open as always and LeBron and Carmelo get buckets as always, but it isn’t nearly enough.
Class of 2009 wins, 204-108
MATCHUP 2
(5) Class of 2013 vs
(12) Class of 2008
Did you forget about Anthony Bennett? Because I did. In fact, he played for my Timberwolves for a full year, was the #1 pick in 2013 and I still forgot that he existed until now. Despite his absence, the class of 2013 sets itself up as an early frontrunner as Victor Oladipo, CJ McCollum and Tim Hardaway prove their experience playing off a ball-dominant star. For Team ’08, Russ, D-Rose, K-Love and Eric Gordon show glimpses of their former selves but it’s hard to get anything going against Gobert and Giannis.
Class of 2013 wins, 113-82
MATCHUP 3
(6) Class of 2014 vs
(11) Class of 2006
This is the type of game that would be awesome to watch. The “Bounce Bros” Zach LaVine and Andrew Wiggins are re-united, Nikola Jokic and Joel Embiid share a frontcourt, Kyrie Irving’s current (Dinwiddie) and former (Smart) backups-ish combine forces… on the other side, veterans who still have serious game team up to take on the young guns.
From the tip, C.O. ’14 realizes they have to stagger their ball-dominant starters, mixing in Joe Harris, Bogdan Bogdanovic and Clint Capela early on. C.O. ’06 runs its offense through Kyle Lowry and LaMarcus Aldridge pick-and-roll action and gets out to an early lead. It’s a close game throughout, but ultimately Team ‘06’s lack of depth catches up to them as Embiid and Jokic dominate the fourth quarter.
Class of 2014 wins, 112-102
MATCHUP 4
(7) Class of 2018 vs
(10) Class of 2005
It’s pretty crazy that this 2018 class already has two All-Star starters. Granted, there’s a case to be made that Trae Young shouldn’t be an All-Star at all given his poor defense and team record, but it’s the East and he puts up serious points. And it’s not just the top of the ’18 class that’s impressive. Aaron Holiday, Jalen Brunson and Devonte Graham were late selections who have been playing great lately. DeAndre Ayton still has high potential.
Chris Paul could make a team of high schoolers look decent but he and Lou Williams don’t have quite enough to keep up.
Class of 2018 wins, 104-86
ROUND 2
MATCHUP 5
(1) Class of 2016 vs
(8) Class of 2009
The game starts slow, as both teams try to find a rhythm. Team ’16 has a hard time getting into a flow but gets some easy offense off Simmons-Siakam and Simmons-Sabonis pick-and-rolls. Brown and Brogdon spot up and make plays when needed. For Team ’09, Curry and Harden get hot at the same time in the third quarter to take a 10-point lead into the fourth. It’s back and forth throughout the fourth, but the veteran bench of Team ’09 makes key plays at important times to pull out the W.
Class of 2009 wins, 108-103
MATCHUP 6
(4) Class of 2017 vs
(5) Class of 2013
Team USA teammates DeAaron Fox, Donovan Mitchell and Jayson Tatum take on Giannis once again after beating Team Greece in the 2019 FIBA World Cup. Unfortunately, this time around Giannis has Rudy Gobert, Victor Oladipo and CJ McCollum alongside him and there’s not much pre-existing team chemistry can do to slow them down. Jonathan Isaac and Bam Adebayo help defensively, but it’s not enough. For Team ’17, Luke Kennard and OG Anunoby knock down shots all night long, but they’re matched by Dennis Shröeder and Kelly Olynyk of ’13.
Team Giannis wins, 118-112
MATCHUP 7
(3) Class of 2012 vs
(6) Class of 2014
It’s true that Khris Middleton is on a great team and Brad Beal is on a horrible one, but there’s no way Middleton is an All-Star and Beal isn’t. Regardless, Team 2012 comes out in the seventh game of the tourney firing on all cylinders. Lillard knocks down shots, Beal knocks down shots, Evan Fournier comes in off the bench and knocks down shots. Joel Embiid and Nikola Jokic get in a fight in the second quarter and both get ejected. Luckily for Team ’14, they still have enough microwave scorers to avoid a total disgrace, but it’s mostly over by the start of the fourth.
Class of 2012 wins, 120-95
MATCHUP 8
(2) Class of 2011 vs
(7) Class of 2018
Storylines, storylines, storylines. What do you get when you put the King of the North, King of the Bay, King of Flat Earth, King of Queen City, Marcus Morris and Jimmy Butler together on a team? Well, they’d be a really stacked team, for one thing. Trae Young is relegated to the bench as he can’t guard Kyrie, Kemba, or Klay. Luka tries to work his magic, but he’s shut down by a lethal mix of Jimmy Butler, Klay Thompson and Kawhi Leonard. It’s over early.
Class of 2011 wins, 112-87
ROUND 3
MATCHUP 9 (SEMIFINALS)
(8) Class of 2009 vs
(5) Class of 2013
Matchup 9 features C.O. ‘09’s loaded backcourt against C.O. ‘13’s loaded frontcourt. Team ‘09’s bench is stonger once again, but their lack of a backup center hurts them against Gobert and Adams. Blake Griffin can’t get anything going and the game ebbs and flows with the shooting of Curry and Harden. Team ’13 holds an 8-point lead with two minutes left but four 3’s in a row by Harden and Danny Green force the game into overtime. Giannis scores 9 points in overtime to win it.
Class of 2013 wins, 124-122 OT
MATCHUP 10 (SEMIFINALS)
(3) Class of 2012 vs
(2) Class of 2011
Two stacked draft classes in their primes. And although Team ’11 seems to have more “stars”, Team ’12 has players (Middleton and Green) who make winning plays without the ball. Team ’11 has Davis and Green to lock down the paint. Team ’12 has Leonard, Butler, and Thompson to lock down the perimeter. This game goes down to the wire. No team leads by more than 8 the entire game, until the end, when Kyrie, Klay and Kawhi lock down for winning time like they have throughout their respective careers.
Class of 2011 wins, 110-100
ROUND 4
MATCHUP 11 (CHAMPIONSHIP)
(5) Class of 2013 vs
(2) Class of 2011
Suddenly, Kyrie Irving and Kawhi Leonard are best friends. Team Giannis has gotten into a great rhythm after scoring 113 and 124 (in overtime), and they start off hot again. Jimmy Butler guarding Giannis full-court starts to wear him down as the game goes on and Team ’11 starts to build a lead. Team ’13 goes on a few runs in the fourth but never manages to close the gap.
Final score:
Class of 2011 (TEAM KAWHI) – 115
Class of 2013 (TEAM GIANNIS) – 107
NBA All-Star Mega Weekend Champions: CLASS of 2011